• Chambersburg, PA & Surrounding Areas

Deciding Between a New Roof Installation or a Shingle Overlay: What’s Best for Your Home?

When it comes to maintaining the integrity and safety of your home, the condition of your roof plays a pivotal role. Homeowners often face the dilemma of choosing between a new roof installation and a shingle overlay. This decision is crucial for the longevity and protection of your property. Teflon Roofing, located in Chambersburg PA, emphasizes the importance of making an informed choice to ensure your home remains secure and aesthetically pleasing.

Understanding Shingle Overlays

A shingle overlay involves laying new shingles over the existing ones. This method might seem cost-effective and less time-consuming at first glance. However, it’s essential to consider the long-term implications of such a decision.

The Weight Concern

Adding a second layer of shingles increases the weight on your home’s structure. This additional burden can lead to structural issues, including the potential for the roof to sag or, in extreme cases, collapse. This risk is exacerbated in regions prone to heavy snowfall, where the weight of snow and ice can compound the problem.

Hidden Damage Remains Unaddressed

Opting for a shingle overlay means the existing shingles are not removed. Consequently, any underlying issues, such as water damage or rot, remain hidden and unaddressed. These problems can continue to deteriorate, leading to more significant issues that can compromise the integrity of your roof and, ultimately, your home.

Moisture and Leaks

The space between the old and new layers of shingles can trap moisture, leading to mold, mildew, and rot. Additionally, the extra layer of shingles requires more nails, which can create additional pathways for water to penetrate, increasing the likelihood of leaks and water damage inside your home.

The Case for a New Roof Installation

A new roof installation involves removing the old shingles, allowing for a thorough inspection of the roof deck and structure. This process ensures that any hidden damage can be identified and repaired before installing the new roof. Here are the benefits of choosing a new roof installation:

Long-Term Durability and Protection

A new roof provides a fresh start, free from the underlying issues that may plague an older roof. With proper installation and materials, a new roof offers enhanced protection against the elements, ensuring your home remains safe and dry for years to come.

Improved Energy Efficiency

Modern roofing materials are designed with energy efficiency in mind. By choosing a new roof installation, you can take advantage of these innovations, potentially reducing your heating and cooling costs and improving the comfort of your home.

Enhanced Curb Appeal and Value

A new roof can significantly improve the aesthetic appeal of your home, enhancing its curb appeal and potentially increasing its market value. With a wide range of materials and styles available, homeowners can select an option that complements their home’s architecture and personal taste.

Warranty and Peace of Mind

New roof installations often come with warranties that provide added peace of mind. These warranties can cover materials, labor, or both, ensuring that your investment is protected against defects or installation issues.


Choosing between a new roof installation and a shingle overlay is a decision that should not be taken lightly. While a shingle overlay may appear to be a quick and less expensive solution, the potential long-term costs and risks associated with hidden damage, structural issues, and moisture problems make it a less desirable option. A new roof installation, on the other hand, offers a comprehensive solution that addresses underlying issues, enhances your home’s protection, and improves its overall value and appearance. Homeowners are encouraged to consult with reputable roofing professionals, such as Teflon Roofing, to assess their specific needs and make an informed decision that ensures the safety and longevity of their home.

Site Logo/Icon
  • Location

Chambersburg, PA 17201

  • Hours

Mon-Fri: 8AM - 5PM

Sat: 8AM - 12PM

  • Call Us

Contact Us Today

Copyright 2023 Teflon Roofing
Privacy Policy